Several UK businesses revealed that they are considering adopting a jab or job approach. In other words, no jab means no job.
Many trade unionists and government representatives have condemned this approach. But do you know where your law firm stands?
You can argue that businesses such as care homes have a good point. Shouldn’t they be able to insist that all employees receive the vaccine? However, is there a case for legal practices adopting the same attitude?
Howard Beckett, Assistant General Secretary of Unite, tweeted that “a divisive narrative is being created about forcing workers to have the jab.”
Frances O’Grady, General Secretary of the TUC, threw his hat into the ring. He stated: “The government should make clear that making vaccination a condition of employment is the wrong approach. It may be discriminatory and open up employers to legal challenges. Ministers must remind employers to make sure their workplaces meet covid-secure guidelines.”
The latest word from a Downing Street spokesperson said it would be “discriminatory” to insist an employee receive the jab.
So, what is the legal position? Can you demand that your employees receive the jab to continue working? The legal response seems to be less than black and white.
Employment law requires employees to follow the reasonable instructions of their employer. If an employee is working with vulnerable groups, such as care home residents, a requirement to vaccinate sounds reasonable to protect residents.
That said, employers may not be able to rely on this argument. Especially if they work in a sector where employees can work from home.
The Solicitors Journal recently reported the analysis of Helen Littlewood, a senior solicitor in the employment team at Centrefield LLP. She said:
“Companies must be careful if they are trying to implement a blanket policy of mandatory vaccination as this could expose them to claims of discrimination.
She also added:
“Companies should review their workforce and individual roles – looking, in particular, at the health and safety risks before considering any such policy.”
So, for both businesses and employees alike this poses a key question. ‘If an employee refuses to comply, can they be dismissed?’ From the employer’s point of view, a request to vaccinate could be reasonable in the light of health and safety law. Any refusal to vaccinate by an employee amounting to misconduct.
Employers also often use the “other substantial reason” approach. Employers can pursue this route when an employee refuses to vaccinate. In this instance Littlewood urged caution when considering dismissal on the grounds of failing to comply with a request to vaccinate.
Then there’s the discrimination side of things. Littlewood pointed out that where employee treatment is different depending upon vaccination status, employers risk being accused of indirect discrimination. This is particularly true where certain groups of people may not be able to receive the vaccination at present.
Phased immunisation rollout means younger people are unlikely to be at the front of the queue. That can allow them to claim they have suffered age-related discrimination if they lose a job due to being unvaccinated. Individuals with underlying health conditions face a similar predicament. If you are advised to avoid the vaccine, it could lead to claims of disability discrimination.
Sex discrimination also comes into the frame. The vaccine is not recommended for pregnant women. However, treating a female employee differently during pregnancy may be discriminatory.
Lastly, religious grounds should be considered. Those who are unwilling to vaccinate due to their religious beliefs, expose employers to the risk of religious discrimination.
As easing of lockdown restrictions comes into place, jab or job will become more prominent. Interesting times and interesting test cases will surely follow.
© LawWare Limited 1995-2021
Our clients range from small start-up legal practices to multi-partner, multi-site firms.
Another great customer service experience from LawWare. My laptop had to be stripped back to factory settings as part of a repair - taking hours! In contrast, restoring LawWare took one phone call to the support team and I was up and running in 6 minutes. If only everything was so easy!
As the first commercial user of LawWare back in 1998, we have had no hesitation in remaining with the product through its development. We thoroughly recommend it to any firm looking for a practice management system.
The helpdesk is exceptionally good. Whatever the query there is always a human being there to help. No leaving messages or being advised to go to a website. The best computer service for solicitors I have ever used!
The linking of documents and casefiles saves so much time! I have experience of several accounts packages and I like that LawWare is simple to use and easy to learn. Support is quick and effective and staff are helpful and courteous.
I have worked with a number of Case Management providers over the years but have not come across anything with the attention to detail and thoroughness of LawWare. My colleagues and I have not been disappointed.
I can’t imagine trying to be a law firm in the 21st Century without 21st Century IT systems. Having a ‘single system’ that underpins all the work, whether we are in the office or out, is an integral part of what we are building.
The level of support is the main benefit using this system. The system itself once you have had training is simple and easy to use. We have a great relationship with LawWare and the ongoing support is second to none.
Significant preparation was required to configure and import the data from our old firm. We had to get all clients onto the new system and then learn how to use it. We just find it very easy to use, much easier than our old system.
Being a busy litigator with a growing firm it is incredibly useful to be able to view my files from any location with some form of internet connection. I am a fan, and want to keep working with LawWare to make a good product great.
The switch to the new LawCloud system, which is still on-going, has gone very well. We found the LawWare team without exception to be very helpful and knowledgeable. All queries are followed up and dealt with promptly.